Best Journal Design

2012
Winner: German Studies Review

2011
Not awarded

2010 
Winner: North Carolina Literary Review
Honorable Mentions: La corónica, White House History

2009
Not awarded

2008
Winner: Kairos: A Journal of Rhetoric, Technology, and Pedagogy

2007
Not awarded

2006
Winner: Southern Review
Runner-Up: Virginia Quarterly Review

2005
Winner: Hispanic Review
Runner-up: American Quarterly

2004
Winner: World Order

2003
Winner: Radical History Review

2002
Winner: Camera Obscura

2001
Winner: Theater

2000
Winner: Transition

1999
Winner: North Carolina Literary Review

1998
Winner: Signs

1997
Winner: Gettysburg Review

1996
Winner: Biblion: The Bulletin of the New York Public Library

1995
Winner: The Gettysburg Review
Runner-up: College Literature

1994
Winner: Parabola
Runner-up: Sycamore Review

1993
Winner: VIJ: Victorians Institute Journal
Runner-up: Critical Inquiry

1992
Winner: The Library Chronicle
Honorable mentions: American Literature, James Joyce Quarterly, Georgia Review, Gettysburg Review, American Short Fiction

1991
Winner: Queen's Quarterly
Honorable mentions: Modern Philology, Prairie Schooner

1990
Winner: Women: A Cultural Review
Honorable mentions: Prairie Schooner, American Literary History

1989
Winner: Planet: The Welsh Internationalist

1988
Winner: The Gettysburg Review

1987
Winner: Southwest Review

1986
Winner: English Literary Renaissance

1985
Winner: Rhetoric Review

1984
Winner: Queens Quarterly

1983
Winner: Queens Quarterly

1982
Winner: Bulletin of Research in the Humanities

1981
Winner: Journal Design Award: Journal of Medieval and Renaissance Studies