Starting in 2020, the title and scope of this award changed to include Design achievement in addition to Editorial Achievement.

• 2024: American Book Review

• 2023: Liquid blackness: journal of aesthetics and black studies

• 2022: The Hopkins Review

• 2021: Victorian Literature and Culture

• 2020: Simone de Beauvoir Studies; Honorable Mention: Voice and Speech Review

• 2019: Adoption & Culture

• 2018: Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society

• 2017: Conradiana

• 2016: Nineteenth Century French Studies

• 2015: Diálogo

• 2014: North Carolina Literary Review

• 2013: Public Culture and Translation Review

• 2012: Mediaevalia

• 2011: Exemplaria

• 2010: Writing Center Journal

• 2009: Revista Hispanica Moderna; Honorable Mention: Dutch Crossing

• 2008: English Language Notes

• 2007: Women's Studies Quarterly

• 2006: The Classical Outlook; Runner-up: Canadian Children's Literature; Honorable Mention: Italian Culture

• 2005: Virginia Quarterly Review; Runner-up: Modern Language Studies

• 2004: Meridians: Feminism, Race, Transnationalism

• 2003: Modernism/Modernity

• 2002: World Literature Today

• 2001: CR: The New Centennial Review

• 2000: JAC

• 1999: Composition Studies

• 1998: Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies

• 1997: Connecticut Review

• 1996: The Comparatist

• 1995: Critical Matrix

• 1994: Tampa Review; Runner-up: Modern Language Quarterly

• 1993: Review: Latin American Literature and Arts; Runner-up: George Sand Review

• 1992: Arion; Honorable Mentions: Journal of Value Inquiry, Russian Review, Australian Journal of Communication, and INTI

• 1991: College Literature; Honorable Mentions: Studies in Canadian Literature Études en littérature canadienne, and Queen's Quarterly

• 1990: The Wallace Stevens Journal; Honorable Mention: Christianity and Literature

• 1989: Susquehanna University Review

• 1987: Revue André Malraux